Advertisement
Published Oct 21, 2024
Freshman report: Who should play more, redshirt tracker
circle avatar
Bob Ferrante  •  TheOsceola
Editor
Twitter
@bobferrante

The big picture for Florida State is player development. In a season where the Seminoles (1-6) have struggled at every position group on offense, there are opportunities for true freshmen to begin seeing the field on game days or earn more snaps.

Coach Mike Norvell began his post-practice interview on Monday mentioning "young guys building in their confidence." When asked who impressed him in practice, it should come as no surprise that receivers caught his eye just a few days after three drops were critical drive-stoppers in a 23-16 loss at Duke.

Norvell was perhaps more active on Monday evaluating receivers, and he quickly mentioned freshmen Lawayne McCoy, B.J. Gibson and Elijah Moore for what they showed as preparations for Miami begin.

"I thought Lawayne, B.J., Elijah flashed today," Norvell said. "I thought those guys did a really nice job."

FSU's receivers have struggled with 21 drops in seven games. Aside from Ja'Khi Douglas (24 catches, 354 yards, two touchdowns), there have been no consistently dependable pass-catchers.

A road game at Miami on Saturday is far from ideal for FSU to extend more playing time to a true freshman. But with the Seminoles generating just 15 points per game, 132nd among the 134 FBS teams, coaches are evaluating options.

Any FSU player can participate in up to four games without losing a year of eligibility. So it's a benefit to Norvell and player development to use him in some games moving forward. (There is a new rule that allows for a player to participate in a fifth game if a team competes in a bowl game, but that door has all but shut on the Seminoles this year.)

In the chart below, we'll review which 2024 signees have played as true freshmen:

Advertisement
Freshman tracker
FSU's participation report used to verify which freshmen have played
GamesStats

TE Landen Thomas

7 games

8 catches, 100 yards, 1 TD

RB Kam Davis

7 games

38 carries, 131 yards, 3.4 ypc

WR Lawayne McCoy

5 games

Punt returner

TE Amaree Williams

3 games

1 catch for 13 yards, TD

QB Luke Kromenhoek

1 game

3 of 7, 19 yards (two drops hurt his completion percentage)

WR B.J. Gibson

1 game

Made debut vs. Clemson

RB Micahi Danzy

1 game

Made debut vs. Clemson

CB Charles Lester

1 game

Made debut vs. SMU

CB Cai Bates

1 game

Made debut vs. SMU

OL Tye Hylton

0 games

LB Timir Hickman-Collins

0 games

CB Ricky Knight

0 games

OL Manasse Itete

0 games

OL Jonathan Daniels

0 games

OL Jayden Todd

0 games

LB Jayden Parrish

0 games

DT Jamorie Flagg

0 games

CB Jamari Howard

0 games

WR Elijah Moore

0 games

DE DD Holmes

0 games

DT D'Nas White

0 games

WR Camdon Frier

0 games

PK Jake Weinberg

0 games

Who could see more playing time on offense

Landen Thomas and Kam Davis have seen their playing time increase over the course of the season. Expect that to continue for Thomas. Norvell has not clarified Davis' status for the Miami game after he was injured on his fourth-quarter fumble at Duke.

Lawayne McCoy has played in five games and is already past the redshirt threshold as well, primarily being used as a punt returner. But the receiver has displayed exceptional footwork and route-running in practices. If the coaches feel confident in his understanding of the offense, he is a clear candidate to earn more playing time. McCoy went up to high-point a ball between two defenders in Monday's practice, pulling in a well-thrown deep pass from Luke Kromenhoek.

Beyond listing Brock Glenn atop the depth chart and Kromenhoek in second, Norvell has not detailed who will start or if Kromenhoek could play. It's plausible Kromenhoek does not play at Miami but could play in three of FSU's next four games without burning a year of eligibility if he doesn't play Saturday.

"I was proud of Luke when he came in," Norvell said of Kromenhoek on Sunday. "Thought he located the ball well."

Amaree Williams' future may be at defensive end, but he has three games under his belt at tight end and has played 48 snaps. Expect to see more of Thomas. An argument could be made that Williams shouldn't burn a redshirt at tight end when he will be playing defense in 2025. But with the desperate need for playmakers, coupled with Williams looking like he belongs in the mix, there's reason to play him now.

The best aspect of the redshirt rule is the flexibility to play a freshman in any of four games on the schedule. Gibson wasn't ready in September, but he is making a push. Moore enrolled over the summer and impressed in the preseason, yet he hasn't played. But it's becoming tougher and tougher to rationalize not playing the 6-foot-4 Moore.

If Davis is unable to go, FSU would be shorthanded at running back behind a defined starter in Lawrance Toafili. The coaches could award more snaps to Sam Singleton Jr., who delivered a 95-yard kickoff return for a touchdown at Duke, as well as Caziah Holmes.

Micahi Danzy's speed is undeniable. His drop on the wheel route against Clemson was just one opportunity missed but doesn't mean he shouldn't earn more chances.

Who could see more playing time on defense

FSU went all in with the development of second-year defensive players in September. The top-graded defensive player is sophomore linebacker Justin Cryer (76.1). Another linebacker, Blake Nichelson, has earned FSU's highest tackle grade at 86.4 (Norvell said he missed the Duke game due to injury and is expected to go at Miami).

This doesn't prohibit FSU from playing a freshman linebacker, like Jayden Parrish and Timir Hickman-Collins, but it's clear coaches are investing snaps in Cryer (197) and Nichelson (252).

Quindarrius Jones (98 snaps) has also been a preferred option, for the time, as a second-year player at corner over the likes of true freshmen Charles Lester III, Cai Bates and Ricky Knight. FSU has established corners like AZ Thomas and Fentrell Cypress, and a matchup against Miami is not the point to give any of those freshmen extensive snaps.

All three are options to play. Lester and Bates could each participate in three more games and not burn a redshirt, while Knight has yet to make his debut.

One more reason to play a freshman: FSU's 2025 commitments and targets will like seeing that opportunities are there early in a college career.

Observations: FSU's practice on Monday

Column: There's a process to evaluating, and changing coaches (and assistants)

info icon
Embed content not availableManage privacy settings
Advertisement